+- Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com)
+-- Forum: Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Rock/Classic Rock/Prog Rock/Blues (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? (/showthread.php?tid=10196)
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - SteveO - 05-04-2014
^ Anathema are doing great things creatively...but I don't think anyone can surpass this clip!
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - Onlythelonely - 19-04-2014
For me, it´s 'The Dark Side Of The Moon'.
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - Pink Floyd Fan 1999 - 09-07-2016
Meddle was my first Floyd album, and it's still my favorite
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - bob_32_116 - 10-07-2016
Didn't realise this poll existed.
Despite having heard it a million times, I think Dark Side is still my favourite. This was the one where it all came together.
After that, my second choice would be The Division Bell.
I do like Wish you Were Here, but it seems a little less "edgy" for want of a better word than Dark Side.
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - SteveO - 18-07-2016
I always go back to Animals however the legacy of Pink Floyd's music is outstanding! In reality nearly impossible to name their best! Although I can remember the great stir Dark Side of the Moon (my first CD) and The Wall created in the music world upon their releases!
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - GtrGeorge! - 15-08-2016
Can anyone state a more prescient PF collection than "Momentary Lapse of Reason"?????? The Social-Political statement "Dogs of War", "The turning away"...and the human experience of "Momentary.." and " Learning to Fly". I think it is underated.
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - Jerome - 15-08-2016
A good album but far from their best work. Wish You Were Here is THE masterpiece, followed by DSOTM. The Division Bell is pretty good as well. Animals was the perfect response to the stupidity of the Punk era. Cannot stand The Endless River. Just a rehash of old ideas.
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - GtrGeorge! - 15-08-2016
That's the thing: PF always found a way to transcend the times. The art is bigger than the chord changes,ya know?
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - dort - 16-09-2016
*deep breath* I really like Atom Heart Mother a whole bunch. Its hard for me to pick a favorite, but there you go.
Meddle and Wish You Were Here are the next on my list. It's really close between Meddle and Atom Heart Mother, but I don't really care at all for some of the more singles oriented songs in Meddle.
Which you consider the best album of The Pink Floyd? - Jerome - 17-09-2016
My first Floyd album was Meddle. 'Echoes' is excellent and I also really like 'A Pillow of Winds' - one of their best quiet pieces. Just cannot get into AHM. Like some of Wright's work on this but that's about it. Try his 'Broken China' album. I think it is the best of the solo Floyd stuff. 'Obscured by Clouds' is a Floyd album that seldom gets mentioned but I like quite a lot of it. Again, mainly Wright's work on it.