+- Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com)
+-- Forum: Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: General Music (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=18)
+--- Thread: An Idea For Discussion! (/showthread.php?tid=2652)
An Idea For Discussion! - CMB1888 - 06-02-2010
Both ideas sound good to me
An Idea For Discussion! - Music Head - 06-02-2010
JonG Wrote:As for the first album I agree with Surfer Blood's Astro Coast. Iota suggested it and someone else has seconded it.I was going to suggest that, but didn't want to promote myself.
Instead of relying on charting albums we could use the new releases lists Ed posts.
Glad you did for the reason that nobody will have heard it. Not sure how to select from it though. Random number, but then you could end up with a pop. Not knocking that. If we ever get enough regular participants, I think we should have volunteers for specific genres to be fair. We need to agree on someone to run this or there will be some friction. Or maybe rotate. Of course I'm still in contest mode, so ignore me if you wish.
An Idea For Discussion! - JonG - 06-02-2010
Music Head Wrote:Glad you did for the reason that nobody will have heard it. Not sure how to select from it though. Random number, but then you could end up with a pop.If a pop album is selected first then another randomly selected album can be picked.
I nominate Gryphon to head this up since it was his idea. Or if he doesn't have all the technical know-how (or just doesn't want to) then CP since he offered to post the files. Or both working together.
An Idea For Discussion! - Music Head - 06-02-2010
JonG Wrote:If a pop album is selected first then another randomly selected album can be picked.I second that
I nominate Gryphon to head this up since it was his idea. Or if he doesn't have all the technical know-how (or just doesn't want to) then CP since he offered to post the files. Or both working together.
An Idea For Discussion! - gryphon - 06-02-2010
As I have a lot of energy and enthusiasm for this project but I can't say that I have all the expertise needed I would favour running it jointly with carbon P assuming carbon P is happy with the idea
:biggrin:
An Idea For Discussion! - Music Head - 06-02-2010
gryphon Wrote:As I have a lot of energy and enthusiasm for this project but I can't say that I have all the expertise needed I would favour running it jointly with carbon P assuming carbon P is happy with the ideaYou sure you're ok working with a psycho?:pound:
An Idea For Discussion! - gryphon - 06-02-2010
I can work with a psycho if he can work with an old timer:laugh::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
An Idea For Discussion! - gryphon - 07-02-2010
I have talked with techman about setting up a forum for the album review:
he is ready to do this but, we need to talk about who gets access control and a
few other matters, then we can edit the forum and attempt to put it into action.
I would like to chat to MH and CP about these things and then we will try the
system out and see how it goes.
When we have decided who gets access and the format etc , I'll get back to techman and we'll see what we can arrange :biggrin:
An Idea For Discussion! - Music Head - 07-02-2010
the wheels of progress grind slowly
not sure what you need from me, but fire away.
I haven't heard from tekkie
An Idea For Discussion! - carbon_psycho - 07-02-2010
I am in.... let me know what all is planned..