+- Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com)
+-- Forum: Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Rock/Classic Rock/Prog Rock/Blues (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: Opinions on this performance? (/showthread.php?tid=3603)
Opinions on this performance? - Guilty Undertaker - 10-08-2010
This is for a pseudo-survey I'm conducting. Just wanted to get the opinions of some neutral music fans on the pros and cons of the following performance. Forget which artist is performing it, purely from a musical standpoint I'd like to hear some objective thoughts.
[video=youtube;2nvWLC-CfDk]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nvWLC-CfDk[/video]
Opinions on this performance? - Music Head - 10-08-2010
Pros - I think Bob Dylan was there somewhere
Cons - everything else
Opinions on this performance? - gryphon - 10-08-2010
Workman like performance of a set of people who know what they are doing but have no real spark. I note that the drummer was trying to inject a bit of pace but, the rest looked over paid and under worked!
Opinions on this performance? - CRAZY-HORSE - 02-09-2010
i think you've summed it up perfectly gryphon but compared to his christmas album its a grammy winner! lol
i am a big fan of bobby, but have never liked him doing this song,even tho he wrote it, im not a fan of hendrix but his version rocks, as does U2 version on 'rattle and hum' album
Opinions on this performance? - Thraak - 05-09-2010
CRAZY-HORSE Wrote:i think you've summed it up perfectly gryphon but compared to his christmas album its a grammy winner! lol
i am a big fan of bobby, but have never liked him doing this song,even tho he wrote it, im not a fan of hendrix but his version rocks, as does U2 version on 'rattle and hum' album
I quite like this song but the above version paled in comparison to previous Dylan version I've heard. My favourite Dylan version is the one on his 90s 'MTV Unplugged' album along with Neil Young's version on the 'Road Rock' album of 2000.
Opinions on this performance? - CRAZY-HORSE - 05-09-2010
i thought neil's version was ok, prefer his version of 'blowing in the wind' on 'weld'
Opinions on this performance? - Jerome - 30-01-2011
Can't open it for some or other reason - video deleted??!!