09-06-2010, 12:40
carbon_psycho Wrote:I pity the kids who grow up believing that's music...
Me too...and that brings the subject to the true definition of music. How can we judge that it's not music? Why would a Beatles song be called "true music" and a Justin Bieber song called "not music"?
I know that we all think in ourselves that the Justin song is not real music, that's even the reason I started this thread. But who can put an "official definition" of what is music? There is some noise music, this may be even less music than Justin!
I just wanna point out that even if we are shocked by Justin, we must admit that for those who like him, it's music. Even if I see this as 100% "producer who wanted to make money with young audience", I must accept the naivety of the teens about their definition of music even if like we said, "I pity the kids who grow up believing that's music..."